Identity, ego and the commercialization of the breathwork industry
Identity, ego, the shadow, spiritual healing and the search for our true selves
Over the past eight or nine years, my relationship with breathwork, personal development and spirituality has taken me on a journey I could never have anticipated.
What started as a personal search to reconnect with myself gradually became something much bigger. It introduced me to different practices, modalities, teachers and communities. More importantly, it helped me reconnect with my body after spending much of my adult life operating from the neck up.
My military background taught me discipline, control and the ability to compartmentalise. There were times when feeling wasn’t particularly useful. You learned to get on with the job, put things to one side and keep moving.
But what happens when you spend so long suppressing what you feel that you eventually lose touch with yourself?
For me, breathwork became part of finding my way back.
It wasn’t about becoming somebody else. In many ways, it was about rediscovering the person underneath all the conditioning.
But somewhere along that journey, I’ve started questioning something much bigger.
Not just the direction of the breathwork industry, but the entire culture surrounding personal development, wellbeing, spirituality and the constant expectation that we should always be working towards becoming something more.
And perhaps the most uncomfortable part is recognising how much I’ve participated in it myself.
The identity we build to survive
I often wonder how much of our adult identity is actually a reflection of who we are, and how much is a collection of adaptations we’ve developed throughout our lives.
Think about childhood.
When we don’t receive the attention, affection, security or acceptance we need, we can develop ways of seeking those things elsewhere.
We learn to perform.
We learn to be helpful, successful, funny, strong, capable or whatever we believe might make us visible.
We learn that being somebody might be the way to feel valued.
Sometimes those behaviours follow us into adulthood without us ever questioning where they came from.
For me, there’s a connection I’ve been exploring between not feeling sufficiently seen as a child and the need for recognition I’ve experienced throughout my adult life.
The military gave me another identity. One built around discipline, resilience, strength and performance.
Then came the veteran identity.
Then breathwork.
The instructor. The retreat leader. The facilitator. The person helping others.
All of these experiences are genuine parts of my life. I’m proud of some of them, and they’ve taught me a great deal.
But I’ve started asking myself a question:
Who am I without all of them?
Who am I without the uniform, the qualifications, the business, the recognition or the responsibility of being somebody others look to?
And why does that question feel so difficult to answer?
The spiritual persona: another mask?
This is where I find Carl Jung’s work particularly interesting.
Jung explored the idea of the persona: the social mask we develop and present to the world.
It’s the identity we use to navigate society, our relationships and the expectations placed upon us.
But what happens when we become so attached to that identity that we mistake it for our actual self?
Look at the modern wellbeing industry.
There’s sometimes an expectation that people involved in spirituality and personal development should always be positive, compassionate, conscious, grateful and emotionally balanced.
We’re encouraged to become the best version of ourselves.
To elevate our consciousness.
To find our purpose.
To live consciously.
To become more enlightened.
But where does that leave the parts of us that aren’t particularly enlightened?
The anger. The jealousy. The resentment. The frustration. The insecurity. The selfishness. The moments when we simply don’t like people or don’t want to help anybody.
Are we genuinely accepting ourselves, or are we creating another identity that we believe we’re supposed to live up to?
I’ve started wondering whether spirituality itself can become another performance.
We can become so invested in appearing healed, conscious and enlightened that we stop being honest about what we’re actually experiencing.
And perhaps that’s another form of conditioning.
The shadow: embracing the parts we hide
Jung’s concept of the shadow brings another dimension to this conversation.
The shadow represents aspects of ourselves that we struggle to acknowledge or accept.
We all have qualities we’d rather not see.
We want to be loving, compassionate, generous and kind. But we also have the capacity for anger, resentment, jealousy, dishonesty and selfishness.
And here’s something I’ve come to recognise:
I can be the love and light, but I can also be the shade.
I’m not saying that gives me permission to hurt people, behave dishonestly or avoid accountability.
Quite the opposite.
It’s about recognising that these aspects exist rather than pretending they don’t.
Perhaps genuine self-awareness isn’t about becoming a person who never experiences anger or negativity.
Perhaps it’s about being able to recognise those feelings without allowing them to define or control us.
We spend so much time trying to become better people that we sometimes forget to be honest about the people we already are.
Wholeness isn’t perfection.
It’s recognising the different parts of ourselves without needing to hide from them.
The Presence Process: the way through is in
My experiences with Michael Brown’s The Presence Process have been particularly influential in how I understand this journey.
Two statements have stayed with me:
The way out is through.
The way through is in.
For me, these ideas have become increasingly relevant.
Over the years, I’ve explored different approaches to understanding myself, my emotions, my childhood experiences and the ways I’ve learned to respond to the world.
I’ve spent time studying psychology, exploring breathwork, attending retreats and sitting with experiences that have challenged my understanding of myself.
But there’s something I’ve started questioning.
At what point does the search for understanding become another way of avoiding simply experiencing life?
We can analyse every emotion, examine every childhood experience, identify every behavioural pattern and spend years trying to understand why we are the way we are.
But sometimes we need to stop analysing long enough to actually feel.
Not everything needs to become another lesson.
Not every difficult emotion needs to be turned into a personal development exercise.
Sometimes you’re angry.
Sometimes you’re sad.
Sometimes you’re disappointed.
Sometimes you’re just tired.
And perhaps allowing ourselves to acknowledge that without immediately trying to fix it is part of being human.
The performance of modern wellbeing
Look around us.
The five o’clock club. The morning routines. The ice baths. The gym sessions. The meditation. The supplements. The productivity podcasts. The constant encouragement to optimise ourselves.
Wake up earlier.
Train harder.
Eat better.
Think positively.
Become more disciplined.
Find your purpose.
Build your business.
Become successful.
And somewhere amongst all of that, we’re supposed to find peace.
I’ve spent years training physically. My fitness was fundamental to my survival following my motorcycle accident. Doctors told me that my physical conditioning played a significant role in keeping me alive.
I understand discipline. I understand pushing through discomfort. I understand what it means to commit yourself to something.
But I’m increasingly questioning the idea that we must constantly be doing something to become worthy of the life we’re living.
What if we don’t want another challenge?
What if we don’t want another qualification?
What if we don’t want to become the best version of ourselves?
What if we just want to wake up naturally, have a cup of coffee, walk in the woods, spend time with people we love and enjoy an ordinary day?
Why has simply being human become something we have to work so hard at?
Even rest seems to have become another performance.
We track it, measure it, optimise it and turn it into another achievement.
When did we stop allowing ourselves just to be?
The commercialisation of finding ourselves
I still believe in breathwork.
I still practise every morning, and I still recognise the value of creating spaces where people can step away from the noise of everyday life.
I’ve experienced what happens when people disconnect from their phones, social media, work pressures and constant distractions.
I’ve witnessed the value of nature, stillness, breathing and human connection.
But I’ve also become increasingly uncomfortable with the commercialisation of something so fundamental.
New methods. New names. New certifications. New hierarchies. New experts.
There’s nothing inherently wrong with learning or developing. Good teachers have an important role, and appropriate training matters.
But when does sharing knowledge become competing for recognition?
When does helping people become building a personal brand?
When does personal development become another industry in which we’re encouraged to keep buying, learning, achieving and becoming?
And how much of it is genuinely about helping people reconnect with themselves?
I can’t ask those questions without looking at my own involvement.
I’ve promoted myself. I’ve wanted recognition. I’ve enjoyed being acknowledged. I’ve allowed myself to become caught up in the very things I’m now questioning.
I’m not standing outside the industry pointing fingers.
I’m looking at myself too.
Perhaps the biggest irony of personal development is that we can create another identity around the very practices we believed would free us from identity.
Some things aren’t meant to become commodities
My recent training and experiences in Estonia have reinforced something I’ve been questioning for some time.
There are certain practices, experiences and approaches that I have no intention of bringing into the UK, promoting online or turning into another offering within the wellbeing industry.
And there’s a reason for that.
I’ve seen how quickly something meaningful can become a commercial opportunity.
Someone discovers a new practice, learns a modality or experiences something profound, and suddenly there’s an appetite to package it, promote it, teach it and make money from it.
People jump on the bandwagon. They see an opportunity. They see a potential income stream.
But what happens when the commercial opportunity becomes more important than the responsibility that comes with it?
Some practices require considerable experience, understanding, appropriate training and respect for the people involved.
They aren’t something to pick up, rebrand and sell because there’s a market for them.
My concern isn’t about keeping knowledge to myself or suggesting that others shouldn’t learn.
It’s about recognising that not everything should automatically become a business opportunity.
When financial gain takes priority over competence, responsibility and the wellbeing of others, people can get hurt.
And I don’t want to be part of that.
Perhaps this is another part of my changing relationship with personal development.
I’m becoming increasingly comfortable with the idea that I don’t need to share everything I’ve learned, promote every experience or turn every discovery into something commercially available.
Some experiences can remain personal.
Some knowledge comes with responsibilities.
And sometimes the most responsible thing we can do is recognise that just because we can offer something doesn’t necessarily mean we should.
Sometimes integrity is demonstrated not by what we offer the world, but by what we consciously choose not to sell.
Dibs in Search of Self: perhaps we don’t need fixing
Reading Virginia Axline’s Dibs in Search of Self brought another thought into this journey.
Dibs was a child struggling to find a way of expressing himself in a world that didn’t understand him.
Through Axline’s child-centred approach, he was given something many of us spend our lives searching for: acceptance without judgement, patience without pressure, and the freedom to discover himself in his own time.
Axline didn’t try to force Dibs into becoming somebody else. She created a space in which he could express himself and begin to discover who he was.
It made me wonder how much of our adult lives is spent trying to correct the person we have become.
Perhaps underneath the soldier, the instructor, the father, the business owner and the person who is always trying to help others, there is still that little boy who simply wants to be seen.
And perhaps he doesn’t need another programme, another qualification or another personal development breakthrough.
Perhaps he just needs to be heard.
I say that as someone who has spent years exploring these things. Breathwork, psychology, meditation, retreats, spirituality and the endless search for understanding.
Yet the Black Dog can still be there.
The emptiness can still arrive.
The energy can still drain away.
I’m not writing this because I’ve found the answer. I’m writing it because I’m beginning to question whether the constant search for an answer has become exhausting in itself.
Maybe the point isn’t to keep rebuilding ourselves into somebody better.
Maybe it’s to create enough space to meet the person who was there all along.
The Black Dog: when the search for peace becomes exhausting
There is another part of this journey that I find difficult to put into words.
For years, I’ve explored personal development, breathwork, psychology, spirituality and different approaches to understanding myself.
I’ve invested time, energy and money into trying to reconnect with life and find some sense of peace.
And yet, despite everything I’ve explored, the Black Dog is still there.
I don’t say that to dismiss the value of those experiences. Some have been meaningful, some have changed how I see myself, and some have helped me understand things I had spent years avoiding.
But I would be dishonest if I suggested that all this work has made the darkness disappear.
Sometimes I feel as though life itself has drained the energy out of me.
Not necessarily through one particular event, but through the accumulation of responsibilities, expectations, pressures and the constant effort of trying to keep everything moving.
There are moments when the emptiness feels enormous.
Almost like floating somewhere in the depths of space, surrounded by an endless darkness, disconnected from everything familiar.
You can understand the psychology. You can recognise the patterns. You can know all the techniques.
You can know that you’re supposed to breathe, move, meditate, get outside, practise gratitude and reach out.
But knowing what to do and having the energy to do it are two very different things.
And perhaps this is where the conversation about personal development needs to become more honest.
What happens when someone has spent years working on themselves and still struggles?
What happens when the person who teaches others about breathing, presence and reconnecting with the body is still trying to find his own connection with life?
Does that make the work meaningless?
Does it mean we’ve failed?
I don’t think it does.
But I do think we need to stop creating the impression that enough self-awareness, enough breathwork or enough spiritual practice will somehow make us immune to the human experience.
Depression doesn’t always disappear because we’ve learned another lesson.
Sometimes the Black Dog remains.
And perhaps people experiencing that don’t need another person telling them to think positively, find their purpose or become the best version of themselves.
Sometimes they need to be heard.
Sometimes they need someone willing to sit beside them without trying to fix them.
And sometimes the most honest thing we can say is that we don’t have the answers.
Individuation: becoming whole rather than becoming somebody
Jung’s concept of individuation offers an interesting perspective here.
Individuation isn’t about becoming perfect, permanently positive or spiritually superior.
It’s about becoming more integrated.
Recognising the different aspects of ourselves, including those we’ve rejected, hidden or spent years trying to change.
Perhaps the journey isn’t about becoming somebody new.
Perhaps it’s about recognising how much of who we think we are has been shaped by expectations, experiences, conditioning and the need to be accepted.
And maybe there’s a point where we need to question whether those identities still serve us.
The soldier who had to be strong.
The child who wanted to be seen.
The adult who wanted recognition.
The instructor who wanted to help.
The business owner who has to keep everything going.
The person who feels responsible for everybody else.
At some point, who gets to simply be the human being underneath all those roles?
I don’t have a definitive answer.
In fact, I’ve found myself struggling with that very question.
After years of trying to understand myself, I’ve reached a point where I’m questioning who I actually am outside the identities I’ve accumulated.
I don’t necessarily know what I want my life to look like anymore.
And perhaps that’s an uncomfortable but honest place to be.
Because sometimes the search for who we are becomes so consuming that we forget to experience the life we’re actually living.
Perhaps it’s time to stop performing
I’ve reached a point where I no longer feel the same need to promote myself, constantly share my experiences or convince people that what I do has value.
I don’t want to turn every meaningful experience into content.
I don’t want to feel that every personal breakthrough needs to become a workshop, a social media post or another opportunity to build something.
And I don’t want to spend the rest of my life trying to become somebody.
That doesn’t mean I’ve lost faith in breathwork, nature, personal development or human connection.
It means I’m questioning my relationship with them.
Perhaps I need to spend less time explaining what presence means and more time actually being present.
Less time talking about self-awareness and more time allowing myself to experience what is happening.
Less time trying to fix myself and more time accepting that I’m human.
Perhaps the next chapter isn’t about adding another layer of knowledge, another qualification or another identity.
Perhaps it’s about stripping things back.
Not giving up on life, but giving up on the expectation that life must constantly be something more than it is.
So, have we forgotten how to just be?
I began this journey looking for a way to reconnect with myself.
Along the way, I’ve discovered different practices, explored different philosophies, learned from incredible teachers and experienced things that have fundamentally changed how I see the world.
I’m grateful for those experiences.
But I also recognise that the search itself can become another identity.
We can become so absorbed in healing, growing, evolving and finding ourselves that we lose sight of the person we’re trying so hard to find.
We can become attached to being the person who is healing.
The person who is conscious.
The person who is enlightened.
The person who has done the work.
And perhaps we never stop to question whether we’re simply replacing one mask with another.
I don’t have all the answers. I’m still learning, still questioning and still trying to understand my own relationship with identity, ego and the world around me.
But perhaps that’s where the honesty begins.
Not pretending to have everything figured out.
Not forcing positivity.
Not hiding the uncomfortable parts.
Not performing a version of ourselves that we think the world wants to see.
Just allowing ourselves to be human.
Because breathing doesn’t require a qualification. Being human doesn’t require a brand. And finding ourselves shouldn’t require a lifetime of trying to become somebody else.
Perhaps we’ve become so caught up in the pursuit of healing that we’ve forgotten what it actually means to live.
Perhaps we’ve become so focused on personal development that we’ve turned ourselves into another project.
Perhaps we’ve spent so long searching for our true selves that we’ve lost sight of the person who was there all along.
And maybe the greatest irony is that the more we try to become somebody, the further we move away from simply being ourselves.
Perhaps the real question isn’t how we become a better version of ourselves.
Perhaps it’s this:
Through all this spiritual healing, breathwork and personal development, have we actually become so focused on finding and improving ourselves that we’ve lost connection with who we truly are?
Have we become so busy trying to become somebody that we’ve forgotten how to just be somebody?